This brief review was first released in November 2016 on my now-defunct Small Museums Canada website. Many of the links were dead, so I’ve removed or revitalized them in the version transcribed below. I followed up with an interview with the book’s authors, in this long form podcast. I recommend the latter as a way to go deep into the museum anarchist methodology.

When I am working with a historic house museum, or really any type of museum, I get confusing signals. I always want to ask, ‘What business are you in?’ Some museums seem to be in the business of ‘preserving artifacts,’ leaving little room for interpretation and telling stories. Others seem to be in the business of ‘creating narratives,’ and yet their stories can be internally focused. I’m always looking for examples of museums that are in the business of ‘engaging communities’ … whether visitors, scholars, donors, or those who live and work nearby. This focus on people rather than things, and living people, not just the people of the past, can be the spark that will keep museums relevant today and in the future.
(Ro King, Trustee, The Menokin Foundation, and Chairman Emerita, Indonesian Heritage Society, quoted in AG pp. 50-51.)
Franklin Vagnone and Deborah Ryan’s Anarchist’s Guide to Historic House Museums (Left Coast Press, 2016; hereafter AG) begins with the premise that the majority of America’s historic house museums are managed in ways that are socially and financially unsustainable. The best way to address this deepening crisis, the authors contend, is by creatively engaging one’s neighbors on their own terms. This community-focused approach is not for the faint of heart, since it involves interrogating (and very likely overhauling) one’s institutional mandate before embarking on a protracted, untidy process of listening, discussion, critical analysis and experimentation.
AG is liberally peppered with quotations from museum professionals expounding a commitment to community engagement, including the words that open this review. It shows us how such wisdom might be put into practice through a range of innovative techniques tested in the authors’ classes and workshops. As indicated in an appendix on research tools (AG pp. 199-225), these techniques include video mapping; movement and activity diagramming; Imagination, Excitement and Energy Graphs; Sound Mapping and Anarchist Tags. Many of these methods of grappling with the particulars of historic house experience could be described as cheeky, scrappy, quirky, provisional, experimental and — in ways that I hope to unpack in a future post — tactical.
For all their strangeness, none of these techniques of interrogation and engagement ever seems gratuitously novel or subversive. By daring to try out new methods of institutional critique the authors have given themselves (and, by extension the curious administrator) permission to engage in what might be undignified activities with embarrassing results. But the cost of these experiments is always low, and the risks are nothing as compared with the risks of ignoring actual visitor experience, or waiting around for audiences to meet you on your own terms.
The authors make clear that their techniques of analysis and engagement are subject to revision, and indebted to continuing conversations with “a wide, geographically-dispersed audience of like-minded professionals” by way of Wikiplanning and (since 2012) the [now defunct] Anarchist’s Guide LinkedIn discussion board. As the authors explain (AG, p. 221), the methods outlined in the book are evolving at the speed of social media. In addition to the LinkedIn site Vagnone runs the Twisted Preservationist blog, and the authors have appeared on podcasts including our conversation where Ryan and Vagnone describes the origins and basic tenets of the Anarchist movement.
Frank Vagnone is lucky to have the support of a forward-thinking Board of Trustees in his capacity as Executive Director of New York’s Historic House Trust. Deb Ryan is a registered landscape architect and professor at UNC Charlotte. Her own involvement with the Anarchist project (AG pp. 20-25) involves childhood enchantment with old houses, study under environmental historian John Stilgoe, and impatience with “old white guys” shouting down fresh perspectives at faculty and community meetings.
I don’t need to summarize the contents of this remarkable book, because it’s done quite beautifully in a chart that you can link to by clicking on the image below (PDF).

(Click for full version.)
Starting at 12:00 (COMMUNITY: Acknowledge a Discontent) the five sections and 32 subsections in the Anarchist Chart correspond to chapters and ‘markings’ in the book, which you will need to digest in order to rate your own historic site on a scale of 1-5. Once filled in and colour-coded, your chart will look something like this:

Not surprisingly, Vagnone and Ryan’s provocative book is currently the top Museum Studies new release on Amazon. If your job involves engaging the public in any aspect of material history you’d be crazy not to buy this book.